The Leafs had a higher quantity of talented guys but the quality of the talented guys the Hawks did have was greater. Hull, Mikita and Pilote were better than anyone on the Leafs. Kennedy and Bentley were probably close though. Glen Hall is one of the all time best goalies as well. I give the nod to the Hawks. Tough choice though.
My imaginary record book shows that the Leafs have not even won one of their imaginary match-ups since the days of Lester Pearson and LBJ, and so I voted for the Blackhawks in seven memorable games ending with an overtime goal by Bobby Hull - a booming slapshot upstairs where Canadian moms keep the peanut butter (and where Japanese moms keep the wasabi).